# Cars Commerce account plan

> Cars Commerce runs the Cars.com marketplace and dealer software for about 19,500 US and Canadian dealers, with FY2025 revenue of $723.2 million.

## At a glance

Cars.com Inc., doing business as Cars Commerce (NYSE: CARS), runs the Cars.com automotive marketplace plus dealer websites (Dealer Inspire, D2C Media), trade and appraisal tools (AccuTrade, DealerClub) and in-market media for dealers and OEMs. It is headquartered in Chicago, serves approximately 19,500 franchise and independent dealers in the U.S. and Canada, and reached 26 million average monthly shoppers in 2025. FY2025 revenue was $723.2 million (up 1%), operating income $60.3 million and net income $20.1 million; about 80% of revenue is subscription-based. It had approximately 1,700 employees at December 31, 2025, before an 11% workforce reduction in March 2026.

## Business units

- **Dealer revenue** (89% of FY2025 revenue ($644.1 million)): Subscription marketplace packages, dealer websites, trade and appraisal and media products sold to dealers. Dealer revenue rose 1% in Q3 2026 to $163.4 million on higher-tier marketplace packages and more marketplace customers, partly offset by lower media and solutions products.
- **OEM and National revenue** (9% of FY2025 revenue ($65.3 million)): Mainly display advertising and media sold to OEMs, agencies, dealer associations and auto-adjacent businesses such as insurers. Revenue fell 18% in Q2 2026, called the trough, then rose 15% quarter on quarter in Q3 2026 to $15.7 million.
- **Other revenue** (2% of FY2025 revenue ($13.9 million)): Mainly vehicle listing data sold to third parties; it fell 18% in Q3 2026.

## Strategic priorities

- **Marketplace-centric platform**: CEO Tobias Hartmann is integrating the marketplace instead of scaling distinct product verticals; Marketplace revenue grew over 5% in the nine months of 2026, the best rate in five years.
- **Product-led growth**: Shorter development cycles, Dealer Verified Listings combining AccuTrade condition reports with listings, and a new Chief Product Officer, Mausam Bhatt.
- **Independent dealers via Marketplace Starter**: A free, self-service package adopted by nearly 400 independent dealers; penetration of independent dealers is 20% to 25%, and monetization will come through lead caps and add-ons.
- **Premium+ adoption and ARPD**: Premium+ reached 12% adoption in Q3 2026 against a 15% year-end goal; ARPD was $2,532, up 3%.
- **AI shopping and AI visibility**: Carson, the AI shopping assistant, crossed 1 million monthly users, and inventory endpoints built for AI agents launched in May 2026.
- **Stabilise websites in 2027**: Marketplace capabilities and AI tools come to Dealer Inspire websites in Q4 2026, aiming to stabilize website development and improve its growth outlook in 2027.

## Latest results

In Q3 2026 (quarter to September 30) revenue was $181.9 million, flat year on year, with Marketplace revenue up 5%. Operating expenses fell 7% and operating income rose 72% to $28.9 million; net income was $16.3 million against $7.7 million, and Adjusted EBITDA $55.8 million at a 30.7% margin, above the top of guidance for a third consecutive quarter. Traffic fell 4% and unique visitors 3%, which the company attributes to intentional marketing shifts toward high-intent shoppers, while dealer customers were 19,251 (down 1%). FY2026 guidance was reaffirmed at revenue flat to up 2%, expected towards the lower end, and an Adjusted EBITDA margin of 29.0% to 30.0%, expected at the higher end.

## Investments and deals

- **DealerClub acquisition**: The dealer-to-dealer wholesale auction was bought in January 2025 for $25.3 million plus up to $88.0 million of performance-based consideration through December 31, 2028; none had been expensed by Q3 2026.
- **Cost programme**: An 11% workforce reduction in March 2026 cost $8.5 million; with the April delayering, cost containment yielded $30 million to $35 million of annualized operating cost savings.
- **Share repurchases**: 7.6 million shares bought back for $73.6 million in the nine months to September 30, 2026, on pace for the $90 million 2026 target, under a $250.0 million three-year programme.
- **D2C Media earnout completed**: The final CAD$15.0 million D2C Media earnout was paid in April 2026.

## Challenges and risks

- **AI answer engines and disintermediation**: Generative and agentic AI and AI-powered answer engines could give vehicle information without referring to Cars.com, and AI implementation needs substantial investment.
- **Declining websites and point solutions**: Dealer Inspire website customers are declining and AccuTrade is deliberately de-emphasized as a point solution; management expects near-term headwinds for websites and trade and appraisal.
- **Falling traffic**: Nine-month 2026 traffic fell 7% and unique visitors 10%, as the company cut low-quality traffic in favour of leads.
- **OEM advertising pressure**: OEM and National revenue fell 11% in the nine months of 2026 on shifts in OEM partners' spending and a move to automated buying.
- **Auto cycle and affordability**: Demand depends on car sales, inventory, tariffs and interest rates; 50% of recent survey respondents were delaying a car purchase over affordability.

## What leadership says

> "Organic growth has been challenging in the past. We have good assets, but scaling them will require better integration, simplified processes, and efficient cost and organizational structure." — Tobias Hartmann, Chief Executive Officer, Cars.com Q4 and FY2025 earnings call, February 26, 2026

> "creating an interconnected, Marketplace-centric ecosystem is foundational to our long-term growth strategy." — Tobias Hartmann, Chief Executive Officer, Cars.com Q2 2026 earnings call, August 7, 2026

> "We drove a lot of traffic in the past with a lot of clicks that didn't convert into leads. So, we do not want to do this anymore." — Tobias Hartmann, Chief Executive Officer, Cars.com Q2 2026 earnings call, August 7, 2026

> "we are really here not to compete with our customers." — Tobias Hartmann, Chief Executive Officer, Cars.com Q3 2026 earnings call, November 5, 2026


## Where a supplier can help

- **AI and search visibility tooling**: With AI answer engines a stated risk and Carson and AI agent endpoints a priority, suppliers of LLM, AI search optimisation and conversational commerce tools fit the AI shopping priority.
- **Self-service onboarding for independent dealers**: Marketplace Starter relies on fully self-service sign-up and later monetization, which fits onboarding automation, billing and product analytics vendors.
- **Website platform modernisation**: The goal to stabilize Dealer Inspire websites in 2027 with AI tools and faster mobile sites opens room for web performance, AI content and engineering partners.
- **Efficiency after restructuring**: The cost programme and the 11% workforce reduction point to automation and internal AI tooling that keep output up with fewer people.
- **Performance marketing for leads**: The shift from traffic to high-intent leads and the new CMO fit marketing measurement and performance marketing partners.

_Tamtam's reading of the priorities and challenges above, not the company's own words._

## Key documents

### [Cars.com Inc. Annual Report on Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1683606/000119312526076546/cars-20251231.htm)

Annual report · 2026-02-26

- Cars.com Inc. (d/b/a Cars Commerce, NYSE: CARS) runs the Cars.com automotive marketplace plus dealer websites (Dealer Inspire, D2C Media), trade and appraisal tools (AccuTrade, DealerClub) and in-market media; one reportable segment, substantially all revenue in the U.S.
- FY2025 revenue $723.2 million (+1%); Dealer revenue $644.1 million (89%), OEM and National $65.3 million (9%), Other $13.9 million (2%). About 80% of revenue is subscription-based.
- Operating income $60.3 million (+13%); net income $20.1 million (-58%, the 2024 base held one-off gains); operating cash flow $151.6 million.
- Scale: 26 million average monthly shoppers, over 600 million visits, about 19,500 dealer customers (19,544 at year-end, +2%), ARPD $2,460 a month (-1%), about 7,700 hosted dealer websites, about 1,700 employees.
- Strategy: a "marketplace-centric" platform led by a product-first approach; AI shopping assistant Carson (launched 2025) users generate two times more leads.
- M&A: DealerClub (dealer-to-dealer wholesale auction) bought January 2025 for $25.3 million plus up to $88.0 million of earnout through 2028.
- Balance sheet: $455.0 million debt (6.375% notes due 2028 plus revolver), liquidity $351.2 million; $86.0 million of buybacks in 2025 under a $250.0 million three-year programme.
- Key risks: auto cycle and affordability, dealer consolidation, generative and agentic AI and AI answer engines bypassing marketplaces, search-engine dependence, OEM ad budgets moving to automated buying.
- Tobias Hartmann signed the 10-K as CEO, succeeding long-time CEO Alex Vetter.

### [Cars.com Inc. Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for Q3 2026 (quarter ended September 30, 2026)](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1683606/000119312526449769/cars-20260930.htm)

Interim report · 2026-11-05

- Q3 2026 (quarter to September 30) revenue $181.9 million, flat year on year (0%); nine-month revenue $542.0 million (+1%).
- Dealer revenue $163.4 million (+1%, 90% of revenue), driven by higher-tier marketplace packages and more marketplace customers, partly offset by media and solutions declines; OEM and National $15.7 million (-3%); Other $2.8 million (-18%).
- Operating income $28.9 million (+72%) and net income $16.3 million (Q3 2025: $7.7 million), mainly on lower amortization; operating expenses down 7%.
- Traffic -4% and unique visitors -3% in Q3 (nine months: -7% and -10%), described as intentional marketing shifts toward high-intent shoppers.
- Dealer Customers 19,251 (-1%: marketplace up, digital solutions down); ARPD $2,532 (+3%).
- An 11% workforce reduction in March 2026 cost $8.5 million.
- Debt $445.0 million, liquidity $369.6 million, total net leverage 1.77x; 7.6 million shares bought back for $73.6 million in nine months.
- DealerClub earnout (up to $88.0 million): nothing expensed so far "Based on current performance trends"; the final D2C Media earnout was paid in April 2026.

### [Cars.com Reports Third Quarter 2026 Results (earnings release)](https://investor.cars.com/image/Q3-2026-Earnings-Release-vF.pdf)

Interim report · 2026-11-05

- Q3 2026 revenue $181.9 million, flat; Marketplace revenue +5% year on year from more customers and higher-tier subscriptions.
- Net income $16.3 million (+113%); Adjusted EBITDA $55.8 million (+2%) at a 30.7% margin, 120 bps above the top of guidance; adjusted EPS $0.58 (Q3 2025: $0.48).
- Premium+ reached 12% adoption; ARPD $2,532 (+3% Y/Y); Dealer Customers 19,251 (-1%).
- New self-service Marketplace Starter package adopted by nearly 400 independent dealers (non-paid, excluded from the dealer count).
- Carson AI shopping assistant crossed 1 million monthly users, nearly doubling year on year; Cars.com was the #1 most cited automotive marketplace across major LLMs (Semrush, September 2026).
- Mausam Bhatt appointed Chief Product Officer.
- Nine-month free cash flow $97.3 million; 7.6 million shares bought back for $74 million year to date, on pace for the $90 million 2026 target.
- FY2026 guidance reaffirmed: revenue flat to up 2%, Adjusted EBITDA margin 29.0% to 30.0%; growth in Marketplace, pressure in Dealer and OEM media.

### [Cars.com Q3 2026 Earnings Call transcript](https://www.webull.com/news/15873519611845632)

Executive talk · Tobias Hartmann, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-05

- Q3 2026 call (November 5, 2026): revenue $182 million, Marketplace revenue +5% Y/Y; nine-month Marketplace growth over 5%, the best in five years.
- Adjusted EBITDA margin 30.7%, above the top of guidance for a third consecutive quarter and a record in Adjusted EBITDA dollars.
- Cost programme (April delayering and later adjustments) produced $30 million to $35 million of annualized operating cost savings.
- New leaders: Trent Ziegler (CFO, succeeding Sonia Jain) and Mausam Bhatt (Chief Product Officer).
- Marketplace Starter: free, self-service listings for independent dealers; almost 400 sign-ups, about 80% of their inventory under $20,000, more than 60% fully self-service; monetization later through lead caps and add-ons.
- Independents: roughly two-thirds of dealers are franchise, one-third independent, with a 20% to 25% penetration of independent dealers.
- Carson passed 1 million monthly users; leads up nearly double digits while traffic declines narrowed to mid-single digits; inventory endpoints built for AI agents launched in May.
- Near-term headwinds in websites and trade and appraisal; AI tools come to Dealer Inspire websites in Q4, aiming at website stabilization in 2027.
- Guidance: FY2026 revenue toward the lower end of flat to +2%, Adjusted EBITDA margin toward the higher end of 29% to 30%; Cars.com will not enter vehicle transactions itself.

### [Cars.com Q2 2026 Earnings Call, corrected transcript](https://investor.cars.com/image/CARS_Q2_2026_CORRECTED_TRANSCRIPT.pdf)

Executive talk · Tobias Hartmann, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-08-07

- Q2 2026 call (August 7, 2026): revenue $179.9 million (+1%); Marketplace revenue grew over 7% Y/Y, the fastest in the company's public history outside 2021's pandemic recovery.
- Adjusted EBITDA $53 million (+4%), margin 29.4%, above the top of guidance for a second quarter running; net income $14.3 million.
- OEM and National revenue -18% Y/Y in Q2, called the trough; Q3 guided to sequential growth.
- Dealer Verified Listings launched in June, first product combining AccuTrade condition reports with marketplace listings; feature deployment rate up 80% in 2026.
- Carson AI engaged around 20% of active searches; its users are four times more likely to submit a lead and made nearly 30% of June leads.
- Traffic and UV declines are deliberate: low-quality traffic de-emphasized for leads; Q2 lead conversion up double digits; new CMO hired.
- Website (Dealer Inspire) customers declining; plan to apply the Marketplace playbook and bring Marketplace features to websites in Q3 and Q4, with further investment in 2027.
- Premium+ target of 15% adoption by year-end; 6.2 million shares bought back for $57 million in H1; FY2026 guidance reaffirmed.

### [Cars.com Q4 and FY2025 Earnings Call, corrected transcript](https://investor.cars.com/image/Q4%2725+Cars.com+Transcript.pdf)

Executive talk · Tobias Hartmann, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-02-26

- Tobias Hartmann's first earnings call as CEO (February 26, 2026), six weeks into the job after six years as CEO of Scout24.
- Diagnosis: good assets (brand, data) but "Organic growth has been challenging in the past"; products sold as "isolated and disconnected" verticals rather than one marketplace.
- Plan on three dimensions: product, processes and cost, and organizational structure; the marketplace flywheel is "the growth engine for the platform and all products".
- Ambition to grow beyond low single digits "rather two years out than five years".
- FY2025 (CFO Sonia Jain): revenue $723 million (+1%), Adjusted EBITDA $211.1 million (29.2% margin), free cash flow $126 million, $86 million of buybacks; Q4 revenue $183.9 million (+2%), Dealer revenue +3%.
- 2026 guidance: revenue flat to up 2%, Adjusted EBITDA margin 29% to 30%; Q1 revenue flat to up 1%, margin 26% to 27%; buybacks of at least $60 million; OEM revenue expected flat to down.
- Products: AccuTrade IMS integrated with the marketplace, AI VIN videos (two times lift in website lead conversion), Market Area Expansion, advanced Shopper Alerts into dealer CRMs for Premium+ in Q2.
- Cost: duplicated functions and high personnel expense to be streamlined; sales force being reorganized around "more consultative selling" of bundles instead of point solutions.
- On AI: car buying "requires deep vertical expertise"; Cars.com's 25 years of data and its brand are what LLMs "will always have to revert back to".

## Questions about Cars Commerce

### What does Cars Commerce do?

Cars Commerce runs the Cars.com automotive marketplace and sells dealer websites, trade and appraisal tools and in-market media to dealers and OEMs in the U.S. and Canada.

### What is Cars Commerce's revenue?

FY2025 revenue was $723.2 million, up 1%, of which Dealer revenue $644.1 million. Q3 2026 revenue was $181.9 million, and FY2026 guidance is flat to up 2%.

### How many employees does Cars Commerce have?

About 1,700 employees at December 31, 2025; an 11% workforce reduction followed in March 2026.

### Who leads Cars Commerce?

Tobias Hartmann is CEO, succeeding Alex Vetter; Trent Ziegler succeeds Sonia Jain as CFO and Mausam Bhatt is Chief Product Officer.

### What is Cars Commerce's strategy?

A marketplace-centric, product-led model: integrating websites, appraisal and media around the Cars.com marketplace, growing Premium+ and independent dealers, and building AI shopping tools such as Carson.

_Written by Tamtam from the company's own published documents listed above, read in full. Figures are as those documents state them, for the periods they name. (2026-11-17)_
