# Old Republic International account plan

> Old Republic International is a Chicago-based specialty and title insurance holding company with $8,956.6m of FY2025 operating revenues.

## At a glance

Old Republic International (NYSE: ORI) is a Chicago-based insurance holding company working through operating companies in two segments: Specialty Insurance (commercial lines for businesses, governments and institutions) and Title Insurance. At least one Specialty entity is licensed in every US state and each Canadian province, and about 95% of Specialty premiums come through independent agents and brokers. In FY2025 it reported total operating revenues of $8,956.6m (+9.7%), net income of $935.4m and net operating income of $792.5m. It has approximately 9,500 associates and is led by President and CEO Craig R. Smiddy.

## Business units

- **Specialty Insurance** (about 67% of FY2025 operating revenues ($5,990.9m)): Commercial lines for transportation, construction, healthcare, education, energy, manufacturing and other sectors; commercial auto (mostly trucks) was 42.1% of 2025 net premiums earned, workers' compensation 17.0% and property 13.4%. Net premiums earned rose 10.9% to $5,184.8m in 2025 with $900.0m of pretax operating income at a 93.2% combined ratio. Led by Craig R. Smiddy; it includes 21 operating companies according to the Q3 2026 call.
- **Title Insurance** (about 33% of FY2025 operating revenues ($2,928.9m)): Issues lenders' and owners' title policies plus escrow, closing and real estate information services; 78.1% of premiums and fees came from independent title agents in 2025. Premiums and fees rose 9.1% to $2,858.6m with $139.9m of pretax operating income at a 97.6% combined ratio, above the 90-95% target. Led by Carolyn Monroe; Florida is about 23% of segment revenue.
- **Corporate & Other**: A small life and accident business, the holding company and internal service subsidiaries (investment management, payroll, administration, IT, marketing). It had revenues of $36.7m and a pretax operating loss of $35.6m in 2025.

## Strategic priorities

- **Combined ratio within 90-95%**: Both segments target combined ratios between 90% and 95% over a full underwriting cycle. Management said it wants to be "at a 95 or below" in the softest part of the cycle, even if the top line suffers.
- **New specialty operating companies**: Specialty started five new operating companies in the last four years, which can take three to five years to reach scale. The newer start-ups grew about 40% year to date in 2026.
- **Auto warranty growth through administrator partnerships**: Old Republic is growing vehicle service contracts with market-leading administrators; year-to-date net written premium reached $545.9 million at Q3 2026, and the CEO sees $600-700 million a year in the next few years.
- **Bring Title into its target range**: Title's combined ratio was 96.1% in Q3 2026 and 96.9% for nine months; it aims to get below 95%, partly through a new operating system rolled out with Qualia through the end of next year.
- **Core system modernisation, data and AI**: Several operating companies are replacing policy administration, claims, billing and data warehouse systems, some on mainframe platforms, and investing in data and analytics and artificial intelligence.

## Latest results

In Q3 2026 (quarter ended September 30), net premiums and fees earned rose 8.8% to $2,269.3m and total operating revenues 8.0% to $2,505.4m, while net operating income fell to $181.4m ($0.73 per diluted share vs $0.78). Net income was $243.2m, including a $124.9m bargain purchase gain on ECM. The consolidated combined ratio was 96.1% (95.3% a year earlier); Specialty ran at 96.0% with a $20m credit loss on a guaranteed asset protection account, and Title at 96.1%. Over nine months, net operating income was $538.1m (-11.5%), Specialty pretax operating income fell 15.3% to $611.6m and Title's rose 65.5% to $123.1m. Book value per share was $24.65; the 10-K gives no numeric guidance.

## Investments and deals

- **ECM Insurance Group acquisition**: Agreed on October 23, 2025 to buy farmowners insurer Everett Cash Mutual after its demutualisation; it closed effective July 1, 2026, had about $220m of direct premiums written in 2025, and produced a $124.9m bargain purchase gain.
- **New environmental and property companies**: A new environmental insurance company was announced on September 30, 2025; the start-up Old Republic Property has no premium incentive in its first three years while it builds its platform.
- **IT modernisation programme**: Modern core systems, data and analytics and AI drove about a full point of the Specialty expense ratio increase in Q2 2026, with redundant costs until legacy systems are decommissioned.
- **Capital return and refinancing**: $1,022m was returned to shareholders in 2025 ($897m dividends, $125m buybacks); $700m of Senior Notes issued in May 2026 refinanced $550m maturing in August.

## Challenges and risks

- **Softening P&C market**: Management expects a softer market in the next few years; excluding ECM and the auto warranty write-up, Specialty written premiums grew only 4.4% in Q3 2026, and total property rates were down about 7.5% in Q2 2026.
- **Liability loss trends**: The CEO said legal system abuse keeps pressure on severity on liability lines; commercial auto loss ratio rose to 71% in Q3 2026 and Q2 2026 included $40 million of reserve strengthening in the run-off transactional risk business.
- **Elevated expense ratio**: Start-up costs, IT spend and a $20m credit loss pushed the Specialty expense ratio to 32.0% in Q3 2026; management is working to keep it below 30 excluding the warranty write-up.
- **Real estate and Florida exposure in Title**: Title depends on real estate cycles, independent agents and Florida (about 23% of segment revenue); 30-year mortgage rates with a 7 in front give management pause.
- **Cyber and technology risk**: The 10-K lists cyber incidents, emerging AI and keeping pace with insurance technology among its key risks.

## What leadership says

> "There's no question that we have to make these investments in AI." — Craig Smiddy, President and CEO, Q2 2026 earnings call, July 23, 2026

> "We are sticking with our top-end target, that in the softest part of the cycle, we want to be at a 95 or below." — Craig Smiddy, President and CEO, Q3 2026 earnings call, October 22, 2026

> "$600 million, $700 million in the next few years isn't out of the question" — Craig Smiddy, President and CEO, Q3 2026 earnings call, October 22, 2026, on the auto warranty book

> "fundamentals are very solid in specialty insurance. Prospects are looking brighter in title insurance." — Craig Smiddy, President and CEO, Q2 2026 earnings call, July 23, 2026


## Where a supplier can help

- **Core system replacement and data platforms**: Tied to the IT modernisation programme: operating companies replacing mainframe policy, claims, billing and data warehouse systems need migration, integration and decommissioning help to cut redundant costs sooner.
- **AI and analytics for pricing and claims**: Tied to the data and AI priority and to liability loss trends: tools that sharpen pricing, reserving and claims management on commercial auto and general liability support the 90-95% combined ratio target.
- **Expense efficiency**: Tied to the elevated expense ratio challenge: automation and shared services that help keep the Specialty expense ratio below 30 as top-line growth slows.
- **Title workflow and agent tools**: Tied to the goal of bringing Title below 95%: products that complement the Qualia operating system rollout or support the independent agent channel that produces most Title revenue.
- **Platform build-out for start-ups and ECM**: Tied to the new operating companies and the ECM integration: start-ups such as Old Republic Property are told to build the platform first, creating demand for underwriting, policy and distribution technology.

_Tamtam's reading of the priorities and challenges above, not the company's own words._

## Key documents

### [Old Republic International Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/74260/000007426026000008/ori-20251231.htm)

Annual report · 2026-02-26

- Old Republic International (NYSE: ORI) is a Chicago-based insurance holding company organised into two segments, Specialty Insurance and Title Insurance, with approximately 9,500 associates.
- FY2025: total operating revenues $8,956.6m (+9.7%), net premiums and fees earned of nearly $8.1bn (+10.1%), net income $935.4m (vs $852.7m), net operating income $792.5m ($3.15 per diluted share vs $3.03).
- Specialty Insurance (commercial lines) earned $5,184.8m of net premiums (+10.9%) and $900.0m of pretax operating income at a 93.2% combined ratio; commercial auto is 42.1% of its net premiums earned, workers' compensation 17.0%, property 13.4%.
- Title Insurance earned $2,858.6m of premiums and fees (+9.1%) and $139.9m pretax operating income at a 97.6% combined ratio; 78.1% of its premiums and fees come from independent title agents and commercial premiums were 26% of net premiums earned; Florida is about 23% of segment revenue.
- Both segments target combined ratios between 90% and 95% over a full underwriting cycle; consolidated combined ratio was 94.7% (93.9% in 2024).
- Growth strategy: new specialty operating companies (five started in the last four years, three to five years to reach scale), surplus lines expansion, a new environmental insurance company (Sept 2025) and the agreed acquisition of farmowners insurer Everett Cash Mutual (ECM).
- Expense ratio is elevated by start-up costs and IT spend: core system modernisation (policy administration, claims, billing, data warehouse), data and analytics and artificial intelligence initiatives.
- Capital: $1,022m returned to shareholders in 2025 ($897m dividends incl. a $2.50 special dividend, $125m buybacks); book value per share $24.21; operating return on beginning equity 14.1%.
- Key risks: reserve adequacy on long-tail lines, pricing accuracy, investment and counterparty risk, cyber and AI, real estate cycles and Florida concentration in Title, reliance on independent title agents, catastrophes and reinsurance availability.

### [Old Republic International Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/74260/000007426026000106/ori-20260930.htm)

Interim report · 2026-10-30

- Q3 2026 net income $243.2m (vs $279.5m), including a $124.9m bargain purchase gain on ECM; net operating income $181.4m, $0.73 per diluted share (vs $0.78).
- Net premiums and fees earned rose 8.8% to $2,269.3m; total operating revenues $2,505.4m (+8.0%); consolidated combined ratio 96.1% (95.3%).
- Specialty Insurance: net premiums written +10.5% to $1,636.3m, earned +9.7%; pretax operating income $203.9m (vs $207.7m); combined ratio 96.0%, or 95.9% excluding the auto warranty write-up to retail.
- The Q3 expense ratio includes a $20m credit loss (1.4 points) on a guaranteed asset protection account, plus continued investment in start-ups, IT modernisation, data and analytics and AI.
- ECM Insurance Group acquisition closed effective July 1, 2026 and was accretive to quarterly operating earnings.
- Title Insurance: premiums and fees +7.3% to $823.3m; pretax operating income $50.4m (vs $45.7m); combined ratio 96.1%, still above its 90-95% target; commercial premiums 23.6% of net premiums earned.
- Nine months: net operating income $538.1m (-11.5%), Specialty pretax operating income -15.3% to $611.6m, Title +65.5% to $123.1m.
- Book value per share $24.65 (up 5.7% since year-end incl. dividends); annualized operating ROE 12.1%; $190.2m returned in the quarter, including $113.8m of buybacks; $700m Senior Notes issued in May 2026 refinanced $550m maturing in August.

### [Old Republic International Q3 2026 earnings call transcript](https://fortune.com/company/old-republic-international/earnings/q3-2026/)

Executive talk · Craig Smiddy, President and CEO · 2026-10-22

- Q3 2026 consolidated pretax operating income $227m (vs $248m), combined ratio 96.1%; annualized operating return on beginning equity 12.1%.
- Specialty: net premiums written +10.5%, but +4.4% excluding ECM and the auto warranty write-up, a growth rate Smiddy says "aligns with where we are at in the P&C underwriting cycle".
- Commercial auto rate increases in the mid-teens, above loss trends, with retention near 80%; at least 16 consecutive quarters of favourable commercial auto reserve development. Workers' comp rates down low single digits.
- Auto warranty is a deliberate growth bet with market-leading administrators: "$600 million, $700 million in the next few years isn't out of the question" in annual net premium.
- New start-up operating companies grew about 40% year to date; ECM is running within the 90-95% combined ratio target and lost its external quota share.
- Smiddy expects a softer P&C market in the next few years and will not chase price: Old Republic wants to be "at a 95 or below" in the softest part of the cycle, even if the top line suffers.
- Expense ratio excluding auto warranty write-up around 30; a $20m credit loss on one collateral-deficient program is described as non-systemic.
- Title (Carolyn Monroe): agency revenue +9%, commercial 24% of premiums, combined ratio 96.1%, Qualia operating system rollout through the end of next year; 30-year mortgage rates with "a 7 in front" give management pause.

### [Old Republic International Q2 2026 earnings call transcript](https://fortune.com/company/old-republic-international/earnings/q2-2026/)

Executive talk · Craig Smiddy, President and CEO · 2026-07-23

- Q2 2026 consolidated pretax operating income $238m (vs $268m), combined ratio 95.3% (vs 93.6%); net operating income $186m, $0.76 per share (vs $0.83).
- Specialty pretax operating income $199m (vs $254m), combined ratio 95.5%; $40m reserve strengthening in the run-off transactional risk business placed in run-off in 2024.
- Commercial auto rates up in the high teens, above loss trends, with retention improving as competitors catch up; workers' comp rates flat, premiums -8.4%; total property rate down about 7.5%.
- About a full point of the expense ratio increase comes from IT systems, data and analytics and AI; Smiddy: "There's no question that we have to make these investments in AI", including replacing mainframe platforms.
- Title (Carolyn Monroe): revenue $773m (+11%), pretax operating income $56m (vs $24m), combined ratio 95.1%; commercial 25% of premiums with data centers, industrial and hospitality projects; Qualia operating system rollout.
- ECM: about $220m direct premiums written in 2025, GAAP equity about $145m; same 90-95% combined ratio target; external quota share eliminated from July 1; a bargain purchase gain was expected in Q3.
- Auto warranty partnerships will keep inflating written premiums; Old Republic Property, a new start-up, has no premium incentive for its first three years.
- Book value per share $25.33 (up 7.2% incl. dividends); buybacks remain opportunistic, with a special dividend considered at year-end if capital is in excess.

## Questions about Old Republic International

### What does Old Republic International do?

It is a Chicago-based insurance holding company with two segments: Specialty Insurance, which writes commercial lines such as commercial auto and workers' compensation, and Title Insurance, which issues title policies and provides escrow and closing services.

### What is Old Republic's revenue?

Total operating revenues were $8,956.6m in FY2025, up 9.7%, with net income of $935.4m. In Q3 2026 operating revenues were $2,505.4m, up 8.0%.

### How many employees does Old Republic have?

Old Republic has approximately 9,500 associates, with human capital management run mainly at the operating-company level.

### Who leads Old Republic International?

Craig R. Smiddy has been President since June 2018 and CEO since October 2019; Frank J. Sodaro is CFO and Carolyn Monroe leads Title Insurance.

### What is Old Republic's strategy?

It aims for 90-95% combined ratios over the cycle, grows through narrow specialty operating companies, auto warranty partnerships and the ECM acquisition, and is modernising its systems to use data and AI.

_Written by Tamtam from the company's own published documents listed above, read in full. Figures are as those documents state them, for the periods they name. (2026-11-17)_
