CarMax account plan
Used car retailer revolutionizing buying
At a glance
CarMax is the largest used-vehicle retailer in the U.S., with fiscal 2026 revenue of $25,881.1 million, 256 stores and 27,796 associates.
CarMax, based in Richmond, Virginia, sells used cars at no-haggle prices online and in stores, buys cars from consumers and dealers, runs wholesale vehicle auctions and finances customers through its captive lender CarMax Auto Finance (CAF). In fiscal 2026 (year ended February 28, 2026) it retailed 780,684 used vehicles and sold 538,203 wholesale vehicles, from 256 stores covering about 85% of the U.S. population. Net sales and operating revenues were $25,881.1 million (down 1.8%) and net earnings $247.3 million (down 50.6%). It had 27,796 associates, and Keith Barr became President and CEO on March 16, 2026.
Business units
CarMax Sales Operations
$25,881.1 million fiscal 2026 net sales and operating revenuesUsed vehicle retail ($20,702.4 million, about 80% of net sales), wholesale auctions ($4,504.6 million, about 17%) and other sales such as extended protection plans and service. It includes Edmunds, the online automotive guide whose $141.3 million goodwill was written off in fiscal 2026 and whose sales team signs dealers up for MaxOffer.
CarMax Auto Finance (CAF)
$562.7 million fiscal 2026 CAF incomeCaptive lender financing CarMax retail buyers, with a $16.37 billion loan portfolio and about 1.0 million accounts; it financed 42.4% of retail used units in fiscal 2026. It is expanding into Tier 2 lending and is led by Jon Daniels, EVP CarMax Auto Finance.
Strategic priorities
- Shift into GEAR strategy
- Four pillars introduced by Keith Barr in fiscal 2027: Great Offering, Easy Experience, Add Value and Run Lean, with a strategic update on November 3, 2026.
- Demand-based pricing
- Pricing algorithms now use local market data and flex gross profit per unit; full-year used margin is expected to fall by less than $200 per unit, with the intent to self-fund price competitiveness from fiscal 2028.
- Cost reduction
- $200 million SG&A exit-rate savings by end of fiscal 2027, including a roughly 30% cut of the Customer Experience Center workforce; SG&A per total unit fell 8.8% to $1,621 in Q2 fiscal 2027.
- CAF full-spectrum lending
- Tier 2 origination target of about 30% of Tier 2 volume in fiscal 2027 toward an initial goal of 50% CAF penetration, with nearly $1 billion of Tier 2 originations planned by year end.
- Easier omni-channel experience
- AI voice technology handles 100% of inbound store and customer experience center calls, and the car detail page was redesigned with personalized monthly payments.
- Extended protection plan redesign
- The EPP redesign is expected to add about $35 of margin per unit in fiscal 2027; margins were up $27 per unit in the first half.
Latest results
In Q2 fiscal 2027 (three months to August 31, 2026) net sales and operating revenues rose 19.5% to $7,877.9 million, used units rose 13.8% to 227,391 and comparable-store used units rose 13.0%. Net earnings were $165.3 million (up 73.3%) and diluted EPS $1.16 (up 81.3%). Management attributes the gain about equally to its own actions and to FTC enforcement of all-in advertised pricing. Used gross profit per unit fell $111 to $2,105, while CAF income rose 32.1% to $135.6 million. For the first half, revenues were $15,891.4 million (up 12.4%) and diluted EPS $2.47 (up 22.3%); full-year CAF income is expected slightly below fiscal 2026.
Investments and deals
- Capital expenditure
- Capex of about $400 million planned for fiscal 2027, down from $541.0 million in fiscal 2026, with store openings slowing.
- New locations
- Eight locations planned in fiscal 2027 (four stores, two stand-alone reconditioning/auction centers, two stand-alone auctions); 258 stores in 111 TV markets at August 31, 2026.
- Technology and AI
- 1,308 technology, product and data science associates, the AI assistant Skye, an AI center of excellence and a centralized strategy, data science, AI and pricing team under Jeff Campbell.
- Share buybacks
- Repurchases of $642.8 million in fiscal 2026, paused in Q4 and resuming in Q3 fiscal 2027 at a modest pace, with $1.31 billion of authorization remaining.
Challenges and risks
- Lost market share and a weak fiscal 2026
- Share of 0- to 10-year-old vehicles slipped to about 3.6% in calendar 2025 from 3.7%, and fiscal 2026 net earnings fell 50.6% after a goodwill impairment and restructuring charges.
- Operations too slow and costly
- The CEO says core operations are not yet fast and efficient enough and costs remain too high; CarMax transfers over 2 million cars a year.
- Complex digital experience
- The digital experience is described as too complex and not seamlessly connected to stores, creating friction and hurting conversion.
- CAF credit losses
- Net credit losses were 2.34% of average loans in fiscal 2026, up from 2.03%, with provisions rising to $391.2 million, mainly from 2022-2023 vintages.
- Competition and regulation
- Competition from over 18,000 franchised dealers and online platforms, interest-rate sensitivity, cybersecurity and FTC and CFPB regulation.
What leadership says
“Our core operations are not yet fast and efficient enough. Retail prices and selection must continue to improve, and our costs remain too high.”
“Our focus is to self-fund more competitive vehicle prices through more efficient operations”
“We scaled AI voice technology to 100% of both inbound store and customer experience center calls”
“CAF was once again the largest Tier 2 lender, financing 22% of Tier 2 volume as compared to 10% a year ago”
Where a supplier can help
- Logistics and reconditioning efficiency
- Tied to the Run Lean pillar and the slow, costly operations challenge: tools that cut unproductive transfers and digitize reconditioning.
- Pricing and data science
- Tied to demand-based pricing and the centralized strategy, data science, AI and pricing team: market data and pricing analytics.
- Customer experience and conversion
- Tied to the Easy Experience pillar and the complex digital experience challenge: conversational AI, digital retail and store-online integration.
- Lending and credit risk
- Tied to CAF full-spectrum lending and rising credit losses: underwriting, servicing and collections tools for Tier 2 growth.
- Cost-out programs
- Tied to the $200 million SG&A savings target: automation of corporate and customer experience center work.
Tamtam's reading of the priorities and challenges above, not the company's own words.
Selling to companies like CarMax?
Tamtam finds the companies that match your ideal customer, researches each account and tells you who to contact and when.
Find similar companiesKey documents
Read in full by Tamtam; each summary links to the document itself.
- CarMax Form 10-K for fiscal year ended February 28, 2026
- CarMax is the largest used-vehicle retailer in the U.S.: 780,684 used vehicles retailed and 538,203 wholesale vehicles sold at its own auctions in fiscal 2026 (year ended February 28, 2026), 256 stores in 110 U.S. television markets covering about 85% of the U.S. population, 27,796 associates.
- Two reportable segments: CarMax Sales Operations (net sales and operating revenues of $25,881.1 million, down 1.8%) and CarMax Auto Finance (CAF income $562.7 million, down 3.3%; $16.37 billion loan portfolio, about 1.0 million customer accounts; financed 42.4% of retail used units).
- A weak year: comparable-store used units down 2.0%, gross profit $2,806.6 million (down 3.2%), net earnings $247.3 million (down 50.6%), diluted EPS $1.68 vs $3.21 (adjusted $2.91), after a $141.3 million non-cash goodwill impairment (the Edmunds goodwill) and restructuring charges; market share of 0- to 10-year-old vehicles slipped to about 3.6% in calendar 2025 from 3.7%.
- Leadership reset: CEO Bill Nash stepped down effective December 1, 2025; Keith Barr (former CEO of InterContinental Hotels Group) became President and CEO effective March 16, 2026. The company states plainly that "it is clear CarMax needs change".
- Fiscal 2027 priorities: competitive pricing, broad selection and an end-to-end omni-channel experience; use software, data and AI "in practical ways"; act "with more urgency and intention".
- Cost program: $200 million SG&A exit-rate savings targeted by end of fiscal 2027 (raised from $150 million), including a roughly 30% cut of the Customer Experience Center workforce (about $35 million annualized) and further Q4 restructuring (about $60 million annualized).
- CAF is moving into full-spectrum lending: Tier 2 origination target raised to about 30% of Tier 2 volume in fiscal 2027 (from under 15%), toward an initial goal of 50% CAF penetration; each extra point of penetration is expected to add $10-12 million of lifetime pre-tax income per origination year.
- Investment: capex about $400 million planned for fiscal 2027 (from $541.0 million), four new stores and four stand-alone reconditioning/auction facilities; digital is central (81% of sales digitally enabled, about 37 million monthly site visits, AI assistant Skye, 1,308 technology, product and data science associates).
- Key risks: competition from franchised dealers and online platforms, macro and interest-rate sensitivity, CAF credit losses (net credit losses 2.34% of average loans, up from 2.03%), funding market access, cybersecurity, regulation and shareholder activism.
- CarMax Form 10-Q for the quarter ended August 31, 2026 (Q2 fiscal 2027)
- Q2 fiscal 2027 (three months to August 31, 2026) was a sharp turnaround: net sales and operating revenues $7,877.9 million (up 19.5%), used units 227,391 (up 13.8%), comparable-store used units up 13.0%, wholesale units up 15.9%.
- Net earnings $165.3 million (up 73.3%), diluted EPS $1.16 (up 81.3%); first-half EPS $2.47 (up 22.3%).
- Management attributes the sales gain about equally to its own actions (sharper pricing algorithms, reconditioning savings passed to customers) and to tighter FTC enforcement of all-in advertised pricing, which favours CarMax's no-haggle model.
- Margin traded for volume: used gross profit per unit $2,105 (down $111), wholesale $858 (down $135); full-year used margin now expected to fall by less than $200 per unit. SG&A per total unit fell 8.8% to $1,621.
- New strategy "Shift into GEAR" with four pillars: Great Offering, Easy Experience, Add Value, Run Lean; AI voice technology now handles all inbound store and customer experience center calls.
- CAF income $135.6 million (up 32.1%) on a lower provision and a $16.6 million gain on a loan sale; CAF financed about 23% of total Tier 2 volume in the first half; full-year CAF income expected slightly below fiscal 2026.
- EPP margins up $27 per unit in the first half, on track for about $35 for the year; $200 million SG&A exit-rate savings on track.
- New leaders: Elizabeth Dirgins (EVP, Chief Digital and Customer Officer, from October 2026) and Jeff Campbell (SVP Strategy, heading a centralized strategy, data science, AI and pricing team). Buybacks to resume in Q3 at a modest pace; capex about $400 million for the year.
- CarMax Q1 fiscal 2027 earnings call transcript
- Keith Barr's first full strategy statement as CEO (three months into the role), on the Q1 fiscal 2027 call of June 17, 2026, with CFO Enrique Mayor-Mora and CAF head Jon Daniels.
- Diagnosis: "Our core operations are not yet fast and efficient enough", costs "remain too high", and the digital experience is "too complex and not seamlessly connected" to stores.
- Strategy built on four pillars: Great Offering, Easy Experience, Add Value, Run Lean; objective "deliver strong unit and earnings growth that enables us to consistently reward our shareholders".
- Q1: total sales $8 billion (up 6.2%), about 392,000 vehicles sold, used unit comps down 0.8% against an 8.1% prior-year comp, EPS $1.31 vs $1.38; used GPU $2,177 (down $230).
- Pricing is moving from margin-based to demand-based: external and local market data in the algorithms, more variable GPU; long-term the aim is to self-fund price cuts through efficiency rather than lower GPU.
- Logistics and reconditioning are the main cost levers: over 2 million transfers a year, part and tire selection tools, digitized reconditioning; seven stand-alone centers.
- CAF: penetration 43.3% (up 150 bps), CAF the largest Tier 2 lender; Daniels calls the 50% penetration goal a "midterm objective" that "could be larger than that".
- SG&A $635 million (down 4%); $200 million exit-rate savings on track; no significant new investment, changes to be self-funded.
- CarMax Q2 fiscal 2027 earnings call transcript
- Keith Barr's Q2 fiscal 2027 call (September 29, 2026), six months into the job: used unit comps up 13%, total units up 15%, EPS up 81% to $1.16, total sales $7.9 billion (up 19%).
- Barr and CFO Mayor-Mora attribute about half of the comp gain to CarMax's own actions (COGS efficiencies, lower GPU, pricing algorithms, customer experience) and half to FTC enforcement of all-in pricing.
- Strategy named "Shift into GEAR" and rolled out across the company; agentic AI voice now handles 100% of inbound store and customer experience center calls; redesigned car detail page with personalized monthly payments.
- New leaders reporting to Barr: Elizabeth Dirgins (EVP, Chief Digital and Customer Officer, ex-Volkswagen Financial Services) and Jeff Campbell (SVP Strategy, centralizing strategy, data science, AI and pricing).
- GPU: used profit per unit $2,105 (down $111); full-year decline now less than $200; from fiscal 2028 the intent is to "self-fund" price competitiveness without lowering GPU.
- EPP unit margins up $46 in the quarter (redesign plus a new wheel, tire and dent product); dealer purchases up 54% via the Edmunds sales team and MaxOffer.
- CAF: income $136 million (up 32%), CAF financed 22% of Tier 2 volume (10% a year earlier); plans nearly $1 billion of Tier 2 originations by year end; FY27 CAF income slightly below FY26.
- Buybacks restart in Q3 at a modest pace; $200 million SG&A exit-rate savings on track.
Questions about CarMax
What does CarMax do?
CarMax is the largest used-vehicle retailer in the U.S., selling used cars online and in 256 stores, running wholesale auctions and financing buyers through CarMax Auto Finance.
What is CarMax's revenue?
Net sales and operating revenues were $25,881.1 million in fiscal 2026 (year ended February 28, 2026), and $7,877.9 million in Q2 fiscal 2027, up 19.5%.
How many employees does CarMax have?
27,796 associates at February 28, 2026.
What is CarMax's strategy?
Shift into GEAR: Great Offering, Easy Experience, Add Value and Run Lean, combining sharper pricing, a simpler omni-channel experience, CAF full-spectrum lending and lower costs.
Who leads CarMax?
Keith Barr has been President and CEO since March 16, 2026; Enrique Mayor-Mora is CFO.
Written by Tamtam from the company's own published documents listed above, read in full. Figures are as those documents state them, for the periods they name. (2026-11-17)