Tamtam Try Tamtam free
First Financial Bank logo

First Financial Bank account plan

Client-focused regional bank

At a glance

First Financial Bancorp is a $22.3 billion Cincinnati bank holding company with 151 banking centers in Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky and Illinois.

First Financial Bancorp. is a Cincinnati-based financial holding company that operates First Financial Bank, an Ohio-chartered commercial bank founded in 1863, and is listed on the Nasdaq Global Select Market. It runs a community banking model for individuals and small to medium sized businesses in Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky and Illinois, plus national specialty lending platforms (insurance premium finance, equipment leasing, franchise finance, lending to the financial services industry) and a foreign exchange business. In FY2025 it earned net income of $255.6 million (+11.7%), with net interest income of $642.0 million and noninterest income of $257.4 million, on total assets of $21.1 billion and approximately 2,199 employees at year-end 2025. At September 30, 2026 it had grown to $22.3 billion of assets and 151 full service banking centers after the BankFinancial acquisition.

Business units

Strategic priorities

Grow in and near the footprint through acquisitions
Strategy is to grow within current markets and nearby metropolitan markets, plus acquisitions that add product lines or industry verticals. Westfield closed November 1, 2025 and BankFinancial January 1, 2026; the pending Finward Bancorp deal, valued at about $207.5 million, is expected to close in January 2027.
Build Chicago into the second-largest market
With BankFinancial and Finward, Chicago and Northwest Indiana reach $4.1 billion of deposits and over 40 offices, which management says becomes the company's second-largest market, with room to spend more on the brand there.
Grow C&I and specialty lending
C&I growth is broad-based across Chicago, Northeast and Southwest Ohio; Q4 2026 guidance calls for low to mid-single-digit loan growth led by C&I and Summit. Loan production offices have been opened outside the primary footprint.
Expand fee income
Adjusted fee revenue reached a record $77.6 million in Q3 2026, 28% of total revenue, from foreign exchange, wealth management, client derivatives and bankcard. Nonbank acquisitions to drive fees are considered opportunistically.
Raise the loan-to-deposit ratio and improve efficiency
The loan-to-deposit ratio is about 78%, against a target of 83% to 85%. The efficiency ratio is around 57% and is expected to fall 50 to 100 basis points once integrations are complete.
Balanced capital allocation
Earnings are split roughly into thirds: the dividend (raised to $0.26 per share), retained earnings for organic growth and small M&A, and buybacks.

Latest results

In the third quarter of 2026 First Financial earned net income of $81.2 million, or $0.77 per diluted share, up from $76.5 million and $0.73 in Q2 2026; on an adjusted basis net income was $87.8 million and EPS $0.84, which the CEO called the highest in the company's history. Net interest income was $196.3 million, up 3.1% on the quarter, with a tax-equivalent margin of 4.07%, and record third-quarter revenue reached $273.9 million. For the nine months to September 30, 2026 net income was $232.1 million ($2.21 per diluted share) against $193.2 million a year earlier, with net interest income up 23.1% to $576.2 million on the Westfield and BankFinancial acquisitions. Loans were $13.9 billion (+3.6% year to date) and deposits $17.7 billion (+7.8%). For Q4 2026 management guides a NIM of 4.08% to 4.12% assuming a December rate hike, fee income of $75 million to $78 million and expenses of $150 million to $153 million.

Investments and deals

Westfield Bancorp acquisition
Northeast Ohio bank acquired November 1, 2025 for $324.4 million, adding seven retail locations plus commercial, insurance agency and private banking; cost savings were virtually all realized by June 30, 2026.
BankFinancial acquisition
Chicago bank with 17 offices and about $1.4 billion of assets, closed January 1, 2026 in an all-stock deal valued at $149.6 million, with a $12.1 million bargain purchase gain; systems converted in June 2026 and its multi-family loans were sold in March 2026.
Pending Finward Bancorp acquisition
Munster, Indiana holding company of Peoples Bank with 24 offices and about $2.0 billion of assets, in an all-stock deal valued at about $207.5 million; approved by the Federal Reserve and Finward shareholders, expected to close in January 2027 with conversion in the second quarter of next year.
Capital expenditures and balance sheet actions
Capital expenditures were $28.8 million in the first nine months of 2026; $300.0 million of ten-year subordinated debt was issued at 6.375% in Q4 2025 and the $150.0 million 5.25% notes were redeemed in February 2026.

Challenges and risks

Rising rates hit capital and securities
After-tax unrealized losses on debt securities rose to $361.1 million at September 30, 2026 from $163.9 million at year-end, and tangible book value per share fell to $15.65.
Commercial real estate credit
Classified assets rose to $281.4 million on the downgrade of one $78.3 million CRE relationship; the bank flags franchise, hotel and investor CRE for qualitative credit adjustments.
Competition in CRE lending and for deposits
In industrial CRE spreads are thinning and structures loosening, and some public funds are moving to higher-rate options; the 10-K also cites FinTech, digital asset and stablecoin competition and deposit mobility through digital banking.
Acquisition integration
Three bank acquisitions between November 2025 and January 2027 add integration risk and goodwill impairment risk, and acquisitions drove nine-month noninterest expenses up 27.0%, including data processing up 42.1%.
Cyber and AI risk
The 10-K lists third-party and cybersecurity risk, including ransomware, and AI and generative AI used by customers, vendors and competitors.

What leadership says

“We had a great quarter with adjusted net income of $87.8 million and adjusted earnings per share of $0.84”

Archie Brown, Chief Executive Officer · Q3 2026 earnings call, October 28, 2026

“we really are focused on Finward and getting that closed”

Archie Brown, Chief Executive Officer · Q3 2026 earnings call, October 28, 2026, on further bank M&A

“get back more towards a 83% to 85% loan-to-deposit ratio”

James (Jamie) Anderson, President and Chief Financial Officer · Q3 2026 earnings call, October 28, 2026

“we do think it's not systemic, it's isolated”

Bill Harrod, Chief Credit Officer · Q3 2026 earnings call, October 28, 2026, on the CRE relationship that lifted classified assets

Where a supplier can help

Integration and conversion support
Tied to the Westfield, BankFinancial and pending Finward acquisitions: systems conversion, data migration and branch consolidation services fit a bank converting Finward in the second quarter of next year and targeting a 50 to 100 basis point efficiency gain after integration.
Commercial and specialty lending tools
Tied to the C&I and specialty lending growth priority: origination, credit decisioning and portfolio monitoring tools for C&I, leasing and premium finance, which together drive loan growth.
Deposit gathering in Chicago
Tied to the Chicago build-out and the 83% to 85% loan-to-deposit target: deposit marketing, treasury management and brand programmes for a market management wants to invest more brand spend in.
Fee business growth
Tied to the fee income priority: technology and distribution for foreign exchange, client derivatives and wealth management, which make up a growing share of revenue.
Cyber and AI risk management
Tied to the cyber and AI challenge: security, third-party risk and AI governance services for a bank growing through acquisitions and digital channels.

Tamtam's reading of the priorities and challenges above, not the company's own words.

Selling to companies like First Financial Bank?

Tamtam finds the companies that match your ideal customer, researches each account and tells you who to contact and when.

Find similar companies

Key documents

Read in full by Tamtam; each summary links to the document itself.

Questions about First Financial Bank

What does First Financial Bancorp do?

It is a Cincinnati-based financial holding company that operates First Financial Bank, a community bank in Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky and Illinois, plus national specialty lending platforms, a foreign exchange business (Bannockburn) and wealth management (Yellow Cardinal Advisory Group).

How big is First Financial Bancorp?

It had total assets of $22.3 billion and 151 full service banking centers at September 30, 2026, and approximately 2,199 employees at year-end 2025. FY2025 net income was $255.6 million.

What is First Financial Bancorp's growth strategy?

It grows within and near its footprint and through acquisitions: Westfield (2025), BankFinancial (2026) and the pending Finward Bancorp deal expected to close in January 2027, which together make Chicago and Northwest Indiana its second-largest market.

Who leads First Financial Bancorp?

Archie M. Brown has been CEO since April 2018; James (Jamie) Anderson is CFO and became President in September 2026. Bill Harrod is Chief Credit Officer.

Written by Tamtam from the company's own published documents listed above, read in full. Figures are as those documents state them, for the periods they name. (2026-11-17)