Great American Insurance Group account plan
Specialized insurance solutions
At a glance
American Financial Group is a Cincinnati specialty commercial P&C insurer (Great American) with 2025 gross written premiums of $10,694 million.
American Financial Group (NYSE: AFG), headquartered in Cincinnati, is an insurance holding company that writes specialized commercial property and casualty insurance for businesses through Great American Insurance Group. Its 36 insurance businesses each run underwriting, claims and policy servicing locally and sell mainly through independent agents and brokers; U.S.-based insurers wrote about 98% of direct written premiums. In 2025 gross written premiums were $10,694 million, total revenues $8,174 million and net earnings $842 million ($10.08 per share), with a combined ratio of 91.0%. It had about 8,500 employees at year-end, including about 7,700 at Great American Insurance Group, and Co-CEOs Carl H. Lindner III and S. Craig Lindner, whose families plus employees own about 24% of the stock.
Business units
Property and transportation
39% of 2025 net written premiums ($2,771 million)Federally reinsured crop insurance and other agricultural coverages, commercial auto and alternative risk transfer programs for transportation niches, and property, inland and ocean marine coverage. Underwriting profit rose 57% to $335 million in 2025 on record corn and soybean yields, and nine-month 2026 gross written premiums grew 11% on crop and transportation.
Specialty casualty
46% of 2025 net written premiums ($3,247 million)Excess and surplus lines, D&O and E&O, general liability, targeted markets such as social services and non-profits, umbrella and workers' compensation. Social inflation cut 2025 underwriting profit to $129 million from $279 million (combined ratio 96.0%); results improved in the first nine months of 2026 with a 94.9% combined ratio.
Specialty financial
15% of 2025 net written premiums ($1,092 million)Fidelity and crime, surety, lender services such as lender-placed mortgage property insurance, and trade credit insurance. Underwriting profit rose to $170 million in 2025 (combined ratio 84.4%); a large isolated loss in the European operations reduced Q3 2026 profit to $23 million.
Strategic priorities
- Underwriting profit over growth
- AFG refrains from writing business not expected to produce an underwriting profit; its statutory combined ratio averaged 90.5% over 2016-2025 versus 98.1% for the commercial lines industry.
- Growth in specialty niches
- Organic growth, selected acquisitions and start-ups in niches such as Specialty Construction, E&S binding and Embedded Solutions; the 2026 plan assumed net written premium growth of 3%-5% from $7.1 billion.
- Capital return
- Over $700 million was returned to shareholders in 2025, and special dividends since 2021 reached nearly $5 billion after a $3.50 special dividend declared November 3, 2026; debt to capital is kept at or below 30%.
- Rate adequacy against social inflation
- Renewal rates have risen for 41 consecutive quarters; re-underwriting of nonprofit and excess liability is largely complete and initial loss picks stay cautious in casualty and commercial auto.
- Technology and data initiatives
- Underwriting expenses include software and other costs for IT security, customer experience and data analytics initiatives, including AI and machine learning.
Latest results
In Q3 2026 net earnings rose to $282 million ($3.40 per share) from $215 million, and core net operating earnings to $329 million ($3.97 per share), an annualized core operating return on equity of 26%. Gross written premiums grew 8% to $3,959 million and net written premiums 9%, while the Specialty combined ratio was 93.8% versus 93.0%. The August 2026 sale of Charleston Harbor Resort & Marina added $126 million of pretax net investment income. For the first nine months of 2026, core net operating earnings were $769 million ($9.26 per share) versus $555 million, and Specialty underwriting profit rose 25% to $433 million. Management expects premium growth and strong underwriting results even as some P&C markets have softened.
Investments and deals
- Fixed maturity purchases
- About $1.5 billion invested in fixed maturities in Q3 2026 at yields of approximately 6%, lifting P&C portfolio duration to 3.6 years from 3.1.
- Charleston Harbor sale
- The August 2026 sale of Charleston Harbor Resort & Marina generated $126 million of pretax net investment income, split evenly between the P&C segment and the parent.
- Senior notes issue
- $350 million of 5.00% Senior Notes due 2035 were issued in September 2025.
- Catastrophe reinsurance
- A January 2026 U.S. catastrophe program of $205 million in excess of a $70 million retention, plus the Riverfront Re catastrophe bond through December 31, 2028.
Challenges and risks
- Social inflation in casualty
- Social inflation drove Specialty casualty underwriting profit down to $129 million in 2025 and remains a key pressure on loss trends.
- California workers' compensation
- Cumulative trauma claims push frequency up in California, where AFG has a moderate underwriting loss and filed a 9.1% rate increase.
- Alternative investment returns
- Alternatives returned 2.5% in 2025 versus 6.1%, weighed down by multifamily oversupply, and the recovery is coming slower than expected.
- Softening markets
- Management is mindful of pockets of softening rates, and some P&C markets have softened in 2026.
- Catastrophes and large losses
- Catastrophe losses were $137 million in 2025, and a large isolated European fire and business interruption loss hit Specialty financial in Q3 2026.
What leadership says
“our highest ever for a third quarter”
“Capital management is one of our highest priorities”
“We think that we're in the early stages of a turn”
Where a supplier can help
- Data analytics and AI for underwriting
- AFG is spending on data analytics, AI and machine learning initiatives; tools that sharpen loss picks against social inflation tie directly to its underwriting-first priority.
- IT security
- IT security is a named expense initiative and cybersecurity a stated risk, opening room for security vendors across its 36 decentralised businesses.
- Customer and agent experience
- With distribution through several thousand independent agents and brokers and a customer experience programme under way, agency portals and servicing tools fit its priorities.
- Support for start-up businesses
- New start-ups in Specialty Construction, E&S binding and Embedded Solutions need policy administration, distribution and claims capabilities.
Tamtam's reading of the priorities and challenges above, not the company's own words.
Selling to companies like Great American Insurance Group?
Tamtam finds the companies that match your ideal customer, researches each account and tells you who to contact and when.
Find similar companiesKey documents
Read in full by Tamtam; each summary links to the document itself.
- American Financial Group, Inc. Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025
- American Financial Group (NYSE: AFG, Cincinnati) is an insurance holding company; through Great American Insurance Group it writes specialized commercial property and casualty insurance for businesses via 36 insurance businesses, sold mainly through independent agents and brokers.
- 2025: gross written premiums $10,694 million, net written premiums $7,110 million (vs $7,139 million), net earned premiums $7,046 million; total revenues $8,174 million.
- Net earnings $842 million ($10.08 per share) vs $887 million; core net operating earnings $860 million ($10.29 per share) vs $902 million, as lower alternative-investment income (2.5% return vs 6.1%) outweighed higher underwriting profit.
- Underwriting gain $629 million, combined ratio 91.0% (91.2% in 2024); statutory combined ratio averaged 90.5% over 2016-2025 vs 98.1% for commercial lines industry.
- Three Specialty sub-segments by 2025 net written premiums: Property and transportation $2,771 million (39%), Specialty casualty $3,247 million (46%), Specialty financial $1,092 million (15%).
- Social inflation hit Specialty casualty: underwriting profit fell to $129 million from $279 million (combined ratio 96.0%), while crop drove Property and transportation profit up 57% to $335 million.
- Capital: $17.18 billion investment portfolio, shareholders' equity $4,820 million, debt to capital 27.5% (target at or below 30%); special dividends $334 million and $99 million buybacks in 2025, a further $1.50 special declared in February 2026.
- About 8,500 employees (about 7,700 at Great American Insurance Group); Co-CEOs Carl H. Lindner III and S. Craig Lindner, whose families plus employees own about 24% of the stock.
- Outlook: management expects overall premium growth and strong underwriting results, and improved alternative-investment returns from the second half of 2026.
- American Financial Group, Inc. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026
- Q3 2026 net earnings $282 million ($3.40 per share) vs $215 million ($2.58); core net operating earnings $329 million ($3.97 per share) vs $224 million ($2.69), driven by higher net investment income.
- Nine months 2026: net earnings $721 million ($8.68 per share) vs $543 million; core net operating earnings $769 million ($9.26 per share) vs $555 million ($6.65).
- The August 2026 sale of Charleston Harbor Resort & Marina generated $126 million of pretax net investment income, split evenly between the P&C segment and the parent.
- Q3 gross written premiums $3,959 million (+8%), net written premiums $2,454 million (+9%); Specialty combined ratio 93.8% vs 93.0%, underwriting profit $133 million vs $139 million.
- Nine months: Specialty underwriting profit $433 million vs $347 million (+25%), combined ratio 92.0% vs 93.3%; GWP up 7% to $9,244 million; renewal rates up approximately 4% (approximately 5% excluding workers' compensation).
- Property and transportation leads growth (nine-month GWP +11% on crop and transportation); Specialty financial absorbed a large isolated loss in the European operations.
- Capital: 847,839 shares repurchased for $112 million and a $1.50 special dividend in the first nine months; a $3.50 special dividend declared November 3, 2026; debt to capital 26.4%.
- Outlook: premium growth and strong underwriting results expected even as some P&C markets have softened; better alternative-investment returns expected to lift income into 2027.
- American Financial Group Q3 2026 earnings call transcript
- Core net operating earnings of $3.97 per share in Q3 2026, up 48%, an annualized core operating return on equity of 26%; Carl Lindner calls it the highest third quarter ever.
- The Charleston Harbor Resort and Marina sale generated $126 million pretax and $1.21 per share; Craig Lindner says core income was a record even excluding it.
- Gross and net written premiums up 8% and 9%; renewal rates up approximately 6% excluding workers' comp, 41 consecutive quarters of overall rate increases; Specialty combined ratio 93.8.
- Commercial auto liability made an underwriting profit for a third consecutive quarter, with renewal rates up about 15%; commercial auto is around 12% of the business.
- Craig Lindner invested about $1.5 billion in fixed maturities in the quarter at yields of approximately 6%, lifting P&C portfolio duration to 3.6 years from 3.1.
- Capital: regular quarterly dividend raised 10.2%, $3.50 special dividend (about $290 million), $59 per share or nearly $5 billion of specials since 2021.
- Risks flagged: California workers' comp cumulative trauma claims, social inflation in casualty, a large European fire and business interruption loss in Specialty Financial, and a slower multifamily recovery affecting alternative-investment returns.
- American Financial Group Q4 and full year 2025 earnings call transcript
- 2025 core net operating earnings of $10.29 per share and a core operating return on equity of 18.2%; Q4 core earnings of $3.65 per share, a 25.2% annualized ROE.
- Over $700 million returned to shareholders in 2025 ($334 million special dividends, $274 million regular dividends, $99 million buybacks); $6.3 billion over five years.
- Q4 Specialty combined ratio 84.1, underwriting profit up 41%, a quarterly record led by crop (Property and Transportation at 70.6%).
- 2026 business plan assumptions: net written premium growth of 3%-5% from $7.1 billion, combined ratio of approximately 92.5%, reinvestment rate approximately 5.25%, about 8% return on $2.8 billion of alternatives, giving core EPS of approximately $11 and core ROE of approximately 18%.
- Growth bets: start-ups in Specialty Construction, E&S binding and Embedded Solutions; social inflation re-underwriting in nonprofit and excess liability largely complete.
- Watch points: California workers' comp (cumulative trauma, rate up about 10% in Q4), casualty loss picks kept cautious, and multifamily oversupply weighing on alternative returns (0.9% annualized in Q4).
Questions about Great American Insurance Group
What does American Financial Group do?
Through Great American Insurance Group, AFG writes specialized commercial property and casualty insurance for businesses via 36 insurance businesses, sold mainly through independent agents and brokers.
What is American Financial Group's revenue?
Total revenues were $8,174 million in 2025, with gross written premiums of $10,694 million and net earnings of $842 million.
How many employees does American Financial Group have?
About 8,500 employees at December 31, 2025, including about 7,700 at Great American Insurance Group.
Who leads American Financial Group?
Co-CEOs Carl H. Lindner III and S. Craig Lindner; Brian Hertzman is CFO.
Written by Tamtam from the company's own published documents listed above, read in full. Figures are as those documents state them, for the periods they name. (2026-11-17)